Clarity from Confusion: Understanding “Complicated” Energy in Relationships

As a relationship expert, I have observed a persistent pattern that reveals a painful attachment history at the core of your romantic bond: Confusion is Clarity.

Before concluding that confusion energy signals an unhealthy relationship, it’s crucial to reflect on your own attachment patterns. Have you taken steps to understand and address your attachment style? Self-awareness is key to distinguishing between internal attachment issues and external relational problems.

Are you left wondering whether someone is interested, even after you have started “dating” or cultivating intimacy? Are you on the receiving end of mixed signals and irregular communication rhythms? Are you puzzled by fluctuating periods of warmth and withdrawal?

IT’S NOT YOU, the individual; IT’S YOU, the couple.

Consider yourself warned.

Relationships can be incredibly rewarding, but they can also be sources of emotional turmoil. It’s essential to differentiate between healthy relationship challenges and toxic dynamics. When you consistently feel confused about your partner’s intentions, it might not just be your anxiety or insecurity at play—it could be a sign that the relationship itself isn’t right.

The dynamic likely is triggering your anxious or ambivalent attachment style due to some subtle (or not so subtle) avoidant or ambivalent cues from them. If you are left guessing, that is an opportunity for you to answer the question of their commitment by reaffirming your own—to yourself.

Walk away and wish them the very best. Do not squander your precious time.

The Concept of Confusion Energy

“Confusion energy” refers to a persistent state of bewilderment regarding your partner’s intentions, emotions, or behavior. This feeling of disorientation can be more than just a passing phase; it often indicates a deeper misalignment in the relationship, especially when you’ve already addressed your own attachment issues.

Signs of Attachment Mismatch

1. Disorientation and Lack of Clarity: Constantly feeling unclear about your partner’s interest, intentions, or commitment is a red flag. If you’re always wondering where you stand, it could signal an attachment mismatch.

Many clients are left decoding the cryptic engagement of a love or dating interest. Rather than directing your attention to deciphering their mysterious feelings, note the process as an indication that they are not clearly pursuing or receiving romantic advances. Absent some extenuating circumstances, armed with the clarity that your expectations are reasonable and you’re managing your own anxiety, this confusion is a gift – they are not available at present or able to provide security.

2. Cognitive Dissonance: Experiencing a disconnect between your partner’s words and their behavior, or between the content of their speech and their tone, creates confusion.

Maybe you thought you knew the sum and substance of someone, but something isn’t adding up. For example, they may say they care deeply about you, but act indifferently. They may tell you that you are a priority, but everything else seems to come first. Discordance is not safe. Perhaps you strain to see the good in their intentions and understand the context of their actions, holding onto words over observable evidence to the contrary. You may find soothing yourself and reclaiming your needs (which does not make you needy, but more on that in another post) are better uses of your time. Radical acceptance involves coming to terms with the reality that exists in this moment.

3. Fluctuating Rhythms: Healthy relationships usually have a consistent rhythm. When your partner’s warmth and coldness, or their approach and withdrawal, fluctuate without clear reasons, it can leave you feeling off-balance. Pay attention.

Again, without healthy communication initiated by them about specific circumstances that account for the change, and particularly if this is a recurring pattern, it simply isn’t fair to you. This does not make the love object a bad person – most of this avoidance is unconscious and rarely malicious. Even with empathy and compassion for what may be controlling their time and attention, it may still benefit you to honor your own wants and limits and acknowledge their inability to show up for you.

4. Vacillating Behavior: If your partner’s behavior swings between extremes—being affectionate one moment and distant the next—it can be disorienting and make you question their true feelings and intentions.

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde come as a package deal; it does not behoove you to believe you can date one facet of a personality divorced from the whole. If someone is capable of great kindness and unconscionable cruelty, those are both authentic sides of the same human. You cannot selectively interface with the preferred personality, and it is not your job to change someone, particularly if they cannot acknowledge the issue and personally desire self-improvement whether or not the relationship is doing well.

5. Walking on Eggshells: Feeling like you need to tiptoe around your partner to avoid disproportionate or unexpected reactions to your neutral or minor behaviors? That indicates that something is off.

Healthy relationships should provide a sense of security, stability, and safety, not anxiety and fear. If you feel extraordinarily cautious and find you are suppressing parts of your full personality/spontaneity to avoid their wrath or distancing, then you may find it challenging to be content and feel free with them long-term.

The Importance of Self - Awareness

– Self-Reflection: Ask yourself if you’ve done the work to become self-aware. Have you sought therapy, read about attachment styles, or engaged in personal growth practices? Understanding your own attachment can help you recognize whether the confusion stems from your own issues or the relationship.

– Ownership of Attachment Issues: Taking ownership means acknowledging your patterns without blaming your partner for feelings rooted in your past experiences. This clarity can help you see whether your partner’s behavior is genuinely confusing or if it’s triggering unresolved attachment wounds.

Repetition Compulsion and Undoing

We often unconsciously seek out imperfect relational dynamics that echo our past. We do this because it is familiar. We may also do so in the naïve hope that we gain mastery over the pattern and create a different outcome. Having the control to elicit a different response from someone can feel like closing the loop on a painful early life attachment. We fixed it!

However, it is a setup for failure. Our true agency is in seeking a healthier bond with someone showing signs of secure attachment, clear interest, and consistent words, feelings, and behaviors. Herein lies our power – identify early warning signs, do not ignore/defend/minimize, and work to keep yourself and your heart safe.

Intermittent reinforcement 

One of the most addictive forms of behavioral shaping involves an unpredictable and inconsistent reinforcer. If you get what you’re seeking every time, you feel safe. If you never get it, you can lose interest. However, if on occasion you receive even a pittance of what you desire, you will likely keep ringing that bell until your hands fall off and you have lost the ability to hear. Understanding motivation and reinforcement can help you distance yourself from an unreliable object.

Recognizing Unhealthy Dynamics

Once you’re confident that you’ve addressed your attachment issues, persistent confusion energy likely points to the relationship itself. Here are some questions to consider:

– Do you frequently question your partner’s intentions or their interest in you?

– Is there a consistent pattern of mixed signals or behaviors that don’t align with their words?

– Do they hook you with clear pursuit, and then deviate from that availability, affection, or commitment?

– Do you feel like you’re often walking on eggshells to avoid conflict or negative reactions?

If the answer is “yes” to these questions, it may be time to reevaluate the relationship. Healthy relationships are characterized by clear communication, consistent behavior, and a sense of emotional security.

It is not your job to convince them that their behavior is problematic.

It is healthy to clarify your needs and to communicate your desires at first; after that, it is not emotionally safe to waste your precious energy explaining why they are not meeting your expectations, or even that they are failing you. They may never get it or agree. You still can terminate things with respect, compassion, and understanding. We are all holding the past within ourselves, and you can say goodbye without blaming or pathologizing someone.

“Remember, a healthy relationship should enhance your well-being…”

Conclusion

Confusion energy in a relationship, once you’ve taken ownership of your own attachment issues and are self-aware, can be a powerful indicator that the relationship is not healthy. Recognizing the signs of equivocation and attachment mismatch, and understanding the impact of fluctuating behaviors on your nervous system, can help you make informed decisions about your relationship. Remember, a healthy relationship should enhance your well-being, not leave you in a constant state of confusion.

Take the first step towards a more fulfilling life.

Contact us to schedule a confidential consultation and discover how our expert therapists can support your journey to mental wellness.

We offer virtual services throughout California, Colorado, and Florida. Reach out to us to begin your path to healing.